Related Articles
7 Critical Rules for American Self-Employed in Israel: Self-Employment Tax and Tax Obligations
Introduction: The Dual Challenge of the American Self-Employed in Israel
American self-employed individuals residing in Israel face a particularly complex tax challenge. Beyond the regular tax obligations that exist in Israel, they must contend with American tax requirements, including the complex question of self-employment tax. This question poses a dilemma for many: Are they required to pay self-employment tax to the United States on their income earned in Israel?
Self-employment tax is a critical component of the American tax system, designed to fund Social Security and Medicare programs in the United States. For self-employed individuals eligible to receive these benefits in the future, payment is an investment in their long-term financial security. However, for Israeli residents, the situation is more complex.
In 2026, with ongoing changes in international tax legislation, it is more important than ever to understand the obligations and rights of American self-employed individuals in Israel. This article will review the seven critical rules that every American self-employed person in Israel must know.
First Rule: Understanding the Nature of American Self-Employment Tax
Self-employment tax in the United States is a federal tax that applies to income from self-employment. It includes two main components: Social Security tax at a rate of 12.4% and Medicare tax at a rate of 2.9%, on income up to the annual ceiling. For self-employed individuals with high incomes, there is an additional Medicare tax of 0.9% on income exceeding a certain amount.
The total tax rate stands at 15.3% of the first income amounts, and it applies to every American self-employed individual, regardless of their place of residence. This is a fundamental principle in the American tax system – citizenship or permanent residence creates a global tax liability.
For self-employed individuals residing in Israel, this creates a complex situation. They may be liable for self-employment tax on their income in Israel, even if they are already paying taxes and social security to Israel. There are no provisions in the American tax code that allow full credit for Israeli social security payments against self-employment tax.
This constitutes a critical issue requiring professional tax planning and careful examination of each self-employed individual’s personal situation.
Second Rule: Determining Residency Status for Self-Employment Tax Purposes
Residency status directly affects self-employment tax liability. U.S. citizens and permanent residents (Green Card holders) are liable for self-employment tax on their self-employment income anywhere in the world. This is true even if they have resided in Israel for many years and have new immigrant or long-term resident status.
Israeli residents who are not U.S. citizens or Green Card holders may be considered U.S. tax residents if they meet the “substantial presence test.” This test examines the number of days the person was present in the United States over a three-year period. If a person passes the test, they will be considered a U.S. tax resident and will be liable for self-employment tax.
For Israeli residents who are U.S. citizens, the situation is clear – they are liable for self-employment tax on all their self-employment income in Israel. This includes income from a private business, freelancing, consulting, or any other economic activity that is not salaried employment.
It is important to emphasize that residency status in Israel for Israeli tax purposes does not exempt from liability for American self-employment tax. The systems operate in parallel, and the self-employed individual may be liable in both.
Third Rule: Foreign Tax Credit and Its Limitations
One of the most frustrating issues for American self-employed individuals in Israel is the limitations on using the Foreign Tax Credit against self-employment tax. The Foreign Tax Credit allows Americans to offset taxes paid to foreign countries from the American tax they owe.
However, not all foreign taxes are eligible for credit. In the case of self-employment tax, the situation is particularly complex. While income taxes paid in Israel can usually be credited against American income tax, Israeli social security payments are not eligible for full credit against self-employment tax.
The reason lies in the different nature of the taxes. Self-employment tax is considered a dedicated tax for social security and Medicare, while income taxes are considered general taxes. The IRS distinguishes between the different types of taxes and allows only partial credit.
In practice, this means that self-employed individuals in Israel may find themselves paying “double tax” – social security in Israel and self-employment tax in the United States, without the ability for full credit.
Fourth Rule: Foreign Earned Income Exclusion and Its Irrelevance
Many American self-employed individuals in Israel hope they can use the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE) to avoid paying self-employment tax. Unfortunately, this exclusion does not apply to self-employment tax, but only to federal income tax.
The Foreign Earned Income Exclusion allows Americans living abroad to exclude a certain amount of their income from federal income tax. In 2026, the maximum exclusion amount is $120,000 per person. This is a powerful tool for saving on income tax.
However, self-employment tax is not affected by this exclusion. Even if a self-employed individual excludes all their foreign earned income from federal income tax, they will still be liable for self-employment tax on that same income. This is a critical distinction that many do not understand.
This creates a situation where a self-employed individual can file an American tax return with no federal income tax liability (due to the exclusion), but still be liable for significant self-employment tax. In some cases, self-employment tax can constitute the bulk of the American tax liability.
It is important to take this point into account in annual tax planning and prepare for self-employment tax payment even in years when there is no federal income tax liability.
Fifth Rule: Strategic Tax Planning to Reduce Liability
Despite the limitations, there are legal strategies for reducing self-employment tax liability. One of the most important ways is proper planning of the business structure. Self-employed individuals can consider establishing a corporation or LLC (Limited Liability Company) that elects to be taxed as a corporation.
When a business is organized as a corporation, the salary the owner receives is subject to self-employment tax only up to the reasonable amount for the work they perform. Additional profits can be distributed as dividends, which are not subject to self-employment tax. This can be an effective strategy for businesses with high profitability.
Another way is full utilization of permitted business deductions. Legitimate business expenses can reduce the income subject to self-employment tax. This includes office expenses, equipment, business travel, professional development, and more.
It is also important to consider income timing planning. In some cases, it is possible to defer receipt of income to the next year or accelerate expenses to the current year, to balance the tax liability.
Any such planning must be done with the accompaniment of a professional tax advisor specializing in international American tax, to ensure that the strategies are legal and appropriate for the personal situation.
Sixth Rule: Proper Reporting and Filing Deadlines
Self-employment tax reporting is done as part of the annual return (Form 1040) using Schedule SE. Self-employed individuals must report all their self-employment income, including that from Israel, and calculate the self-employment tax due.
The filing deadline is April 15, 2026 for the 2025 tax year. Self-employed individuals residing abroad are entitled to an automatic extension until June 15, 2026 without the need for a special request. In addition, they can request an additional extension until October 15, 2026.
However, it is important to emphasize that these extensions apply only to filing the return, not to paying the tax. Self-employment tax must be paid by the original deadline (April 15) to avoid interest and penalties. Self-employed individuals who estimate they will owe self-employment tax should pay quarterly estimated tax.
Estimated tax payments for 2026 should be made on the following dates: January 15, April 15, June 15, and September 15. Failure to pay estimated tax may lead to penalties, even if the return is ultimately filed on time.
Reporting must include income in U.S. dollars. Income in shekels must be converted to dollars according to the average exchange rate for the year or according to the exchange rate on the day the income was received.
Seventh Rule: Professional Specialization and Seeking Advice
The great complexity of self-employment tax for American self-employed individuals in Israel requires professional advice. A tax advisor specializing in international American tax can help in several critical areas: proper diagnosis of tax status, planning strategies to reduce liability, preparing accurate returns, and handling issues with the IRS.
Choosing the right tax advisor must be based on several criteria. The most important qualifications are: professional certification (CPA or EA), specialization in international American tax, experience working with self-employed individuals in Israel, and expertise in tax treaties between Israel and the United States.
The cost of professional advice may seem high, but it is completely justified compared to the potential costs of tax errors. IRS penalties can reach thousands of dollars, and in severe cases even tens of thousands of dollars.
It is also important to understand that different professionals specialize in different areas. A tax advisor will handle routine reporting and tax planning, while an attorney specializing in international tax can help in complex cases or handling issues with the IRS.
Special Effects of the Israel-United States Tax Treaty
The tax treaty between Israel and the United States affects certain aspects of self-employment tax liability, but does not completely solve the problem. The treaty includes provisions for preventing double taxation, but they are limited in scope when it comes to self-employment tax.
Article 24 of the tax treaty deals with the Mutual Agreement Procedure, which can help in cases of double taxation. However, this process is complex and lengthy, and the results are not guaranteed. Self-employed individuals experiencing significant double taxation can consider appealing to this process, but it requires specialized legal advice.
The treaty also establishes rules regarding the place of taxation on self-employment income. Generally, self-employment income will be taxed in the country where the self-employed person resides. For Israeli residents, this means Israel is the primary country for taxation, but this does not exempt from the obligation to report and pay self-employment tax to the United States.
It is important to understand that tax treaties are designed to prevent double taxation, not necessarily to completely eliminate tax obligations in one country or the other. In practice, American self-employed individuals in Israel will still have to contend with tax liability in both countries.
Advanced Strategies for Tax Optimization
Beyond basic strategies, there are more advanced ways for tax optimization that experienced self-employed individuals can consider. One of them is using a Controlled Foreign Corporation (CFC) or more complex company structures. However, these strategies involve many legal and tax risks and complexities.
Another way is planning passive income versus active income. Self-employment tax applies only to self-employment income, not to passive income such as dividends, interest, or rental income. Self-employed individuals can consider increasing the portion of passive income in their income portfolio.
Self-employed individuals working in the technology field can consider selling intellectual property to a corporation and then receiving royalties instead of direct work income. This is a complex strategy that requires careful planning and professional legal advice.
It is important to emphasize that all these advanced strategies must be done in accordance with the law and with professional accompaniment. Errors can lead to serious tax consequences and heavy penalties.
Technology and Digital Tools for Managing Self-Employment Tax
In 2026, there are advanced technological tools that can help self-employed individuals manage their self-employment tax obligations more efficiently. Advanced accounting software can automatically calculate self-employment tax and track estimated tax payments.
Special mobile applications allow real-time tracking of income and expenses, with automatic categorization of transactions. This makes it easier to organize for year-end and prepare tax returns.
Automated systems for paying taxes allow automatic estimated tax payments, which ensures meeting deadlines and saves valuable time. The IRS provides advanced digital tools for paying taxes online.
However, it is important to remember that technology is only an auxiliary tool. It does not replace professional advice or thorough understanding of the laws. Technology can simplify processes and reduce errors, but strategic decisions still need to be made with professional accompaniment.
Long-Term Implications for Social Security Benefits
An important aspect that self-employed individuals must consider is the long-term implications of paying self-employment tax on their American Social Security benefits. Self-employment tax payments credit them with quarters for Social Security, which are required to receive benefits in the future.
To be eligible for full Social Security retirement benefits, 40 quarters of payments are required. For most people, this translates to 10 years of work with certain minimum income. Self-employed individuals residing in Israel and debating whether to pay self-employment tax should consider the future value of these benefits.
Social Security benefits include not only retirement, but also disability benefits and survivor benefits. For families with children, this can constitute significant financial security. In addition, Medicare eligibility at age 65 can be relevant for Americans returning to the United States at an older age.
On the other hand, self-employed individuals expected to remain in Israel permanently and who have no plans to return to the United States should consider the real value of these benefits versus the current cost of self-employment tax payments.
Legislative Changes and Future Forecasts
The international tax landscape is constantly changing, and American self-employed individuals in Israel need to stay updated on relevant changes. In recent years, there have been several bills in the U.S. Congress dealing with taxation of Americans abroad.
One of the important proposals relates to the possibility of full credit for foreign social security taxes against American self-employment tax. If such a proposal is approved, it could solve a large part of the double taxation problem for self-employed individuals in Israel.
Another trend is the increasing focus of the IRS on enforcing tax obligations of Americans abroad. In 2026, enforcement measures are more advanced and efficient than ever before. Self-employed individuals who have ignored their obligations in the past must prepare for stricter enforcement.
It is important to follow legislative changes and consult with professionals about the implications of these changes on the personal situation. Changes in law can create new opportunities or exacerbate the existing situation.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is an Israeli resident who is a U.S. citizen liable for self-employment tax on their income in Israel?
Yes, U.S. citizens are liable for self-employment tax on their self-employment income anywhere in the world, including in Israel. This is true even if they pay social security in Israel.
Can the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion (FEIE) be used to avoid self-employment tax?
No, the Foreign Earned Income Exclusion applies only to federal income tax and not to self-employment tax. A self-employed individual can exclude their income from income tax but still be liable for self-employment tax.
What happens if I don’t file a return and don’t pay self-employment tax?
Failure to file a return and pay self-employment tax can lead to heavy penalties, interest on the amount owed, and even cancellation of an American passport in severe cases.
Can Israeli social security payments be credited against self-employment tax?
Only partial credit is possible, and not in all cases. Foreign tax credit on social security payments is limited and does not provide a complete solution to the double taxation problem.
What is the self-employment tax rate in 2026?
The self-employment tax rate is 15.3% of the first income amounts (12.4% Social Security + 2.9% Medicare), with an additional Medicare tax of 0.9% on high incomes.
How is self-employment tax calculated on income in shekels?
Income in shekels must be converted to dollars according to the average exchange rate for the year or according to the rate on the day the income was received, and then self-employment tax is calculated on them.
Is a self-employed individual who works part-time as an employee liable for self-employment tax on all their income?
Self-employment tax applies only to self-employment income. Income from wages is subject to employee taxes (which are equivalent to self-employment tax) and not to additional self-employment tax.
Summary: Navigating the Maze of Double Taxation
Self-employment tax for American self-employed individuals in Israel is a complex subject requiring deep understanding and professional specialization. The seven rules detailed in this article form the basis for proper tax planning and making informed decisions.
The first rule – understanding the nature of self-employment tax – is the foundation for understanding the complexities. The second and third rules deal with determining liability and credit limitations, while the fourth and fifth rules focus on planning strategies. The sixth and seventh rules deal with practical implementation and obtaining professional help.
The key to success is understanding that self-employment tax is an integral part of the economic life of the American self-employed individual in Israel. Instead of viewing it only as a burden, it is important to understand the rights and benefits that accrue as a result.
Effective tax planning begins with understanding the personal situation, continues with choosing appropriate strategies, and ends with professional and careful execution. With the right tools and knowledge, it is possible to successfully navigate the maze of double taxation and minimize tax liability while maintaining full compliance with the law.
In the evolving world of international tax, investing in professional advice and refreshing tax knowledge is not just economically wise – it is essential for financial security and fulfilling legal obligations.