Related Articles
7 Critical Tax Implications of Debt Forgiveness Every Israeli-American Must Know
Debt forgiveness is a particularly complex area in the U.S. tax world, and for Israeli-Americans the subject becomes even more complicated. When a creditor forgives a debt, the transformation of the forgiven debt into taxable income may create unexpected tax issues. In 2025, with ongoing changes in tax laws, it is very important to understand the tax implications of debt forgiveness.
The issue is intensified when it involves Form 1099-C, the official document creditors are required to send to the IRS when they forgive a debt of $600 or more. For Israeli-Americans, receiving such a form may create tax liabilities both in Israel and the United States.
What Is Debt Forgiveness and When Is It Considered Income?
Debt forgiveness occurs when a creditor decides to waive part or all of the debt owed by a debtor. At first glance, this appears to be good news for the debtor, but from a tax perspective, the situation is more complex. The IRS views debt forgiveness as taxable income because the debtor receives an economic benefit.
The general rule is that any debt forgiveness over $600 is considered taxable income. This includes forgiveness of credit card debts, bank loans, student loans, and any other type of debt. The tax is assessed in the tax year in which the debt is forgiven, not in the year the debt was originally created.
For Israeli-Americans, the tax liability can be double. On one hand, the forgiven debt income must be reported on the U.S. tax return, and on the other, it may be necessary to report it in Israel as well, depending on the specific circumstances and the tax treaty for avoiding double taxation.
Special cases where debt forgiveness may not be considered income include situations such as declared bankruptcy, proven insolvency, or when the payment of the debt would have been tax-deductible in any case. However, even in these cases, a careful examination of the circumstances is required.
Understanding Form 1099-C and Reporting Obligations
Form 1099-C is the primary document creditors send to debtors and the IRS when forgiving a debt of $600 or more. The form contains essential information about the amount forgiven, the date of forgiveness, and identification of both debtor and creditor. Receiving the form is not optional—any creditor who forgives debt at this level is required to send it.
The form includes several key fields. Box 1 shows the amount forgiven, Box 2 specifies interest paid in the previous year (if any), and Box 3 indicates the date of forgiveness. Additional fields may include information about the value of property returned (in case of a short sale), property details, and information about the buyer in case of repurchase.
One common problem with Form 1099-C is that it is sometimes sent years after the actual forgiveness. This can happen when the debt is sold to a debt collector, and the collector decides to stop collection efforts only years later. In such cases, the tax liability should be in the year the debt was actually forgiven, not the year the form was sent.
For Israeli-Americans, receiving Form 1099-C requires reporting on the U.S. tax return. However, it is important to verify whether additional reporting is needed in Israel, depending on the individual’s tax situation and the source of the debt. It is important to remember that the amount on the form does not always accurately reflect the tax liability—sometimes there is room for dispute or correction.
Implication One: Taxation of Income from Debt Forgiveness
The immediate and direct implication of debt forgiveness is that the debtor must include the forgiven debt amount as taxable income. This means that if a bank forgives a $10,000 debt, this amount is added to the debtor’s taxable income for the year in which the debt was forgiven. For someone in the marginal tax bracket of 24%, the additional tax could be $2,400.
The tax is assessed at the regular marginal tax rate, not at preferred capital gains rates. This means the liability can be significant, especially if large amounts of debt are forgiven. It is important to remember that this amount is added to all other income, which may push the taxpayer into a higher tax bracket.
For Israeli-Americans, the implications are even more complicated. On one hand, the forgiven debt income must be reported and taxed in the U.S. On the other hand, depending on the circumstances, it may also need to be reported and potentially taxed in Israel. In such cases, it is important to apply the provisions of the double tax treaty to avoid double taxation.
It is important to note that the tax liability on debt forgiveness is immediate and does not depend on whether the debtor actually benefited from the forgiveness. Even if the debt was forgiven as part of a bankruptcy process or due to severe financial hardship, there is still a tax obligation unless special exemption conditions apply.
Implication Two: Accrual to Income in the Relevant Tax Year
The timing of recognizing debt forgiveness as taxable income is critical. The basic rule is that income is recognized in the tax year in which the debt is actually forgiven, not the year in which the debtor is notified or the year Form 1099-C is received. This can cause confusion, especially when the form arrives years after the actual forgiveness.
Common scenarios involving timing gaps include the sale of debt to collection agencies. When a bank sells a debt to collectors for a partial amount, the debt is considered forgiven that year, even if collection efforts continue. Only years later, when the collector gives up collection, is Form 1099-C issued, but the tax is due in the original sale year.
Another problem may arise when the debtor is unaware of the forgiveness. For example, when a bank internally decides to cease collection attempts but does not notify the debtor. In such cases, the debtor may only discover the forgiveness when the form arrives and may be shocked by the unexpected tax liability.
For Israeli-Americans living in Israel, timing is especially important. The Israeli tax year and the U.S. tax year may differ, so it is important to make sure reporting is done in the correct years in both countries. Sometimes this may require amending prior tax returns.
Implication Three: Impact on the Tax Status of Israeli Residents
Israeli-Americans facing debt forgiveness face another complex challenge—the need to navigate tax laws of two countries. Debt forgiveness occurring in the United States can affect the tax status in Israel and vice versa. The main question is whether the forgiven debt income is taxable in Israel and how to avoid double taxation.
According to Israeli tax law, residents are taxed on their worldwide income. This means an Israeli who receives forgiven debt income from the U.S. may have to report and pay tax in Israel as well. However, the tax treaty between Israel and the U.S. allows for crediting tax paid in the U.S. against Israeli tax liability.
Calculating the double liability can be complex. Tax rates in Israel and the U.S. may differ, and careful computation of the credit due is required. In some cases, the Israeli tax liability may be higher than the U.S. liability, requiring additional payment to Israel. In other cases, the U.S. tax liability may be higher, with no additional tax due in Israel.
Additional complexity arises with different types of debts. For example, mortgage loan forgiveness in the U.S. may be considered taxable income there, but the situation in Israel may vary depending on the details and nature of the debt.
Implication Four: Reporting Obligations and Application of the Double Taxation Treaty
The double taxation treaty between Israel and the United States is a key tool to ease the burden for Israeli-Americans dealing with debt forgiveness. The treaty allows tax paid in one country to be credited against the tax liability in the other to prevent double taxation on the same income. However, applying the treaty requires careful preparation and understanding of the rules.
The credit is granted according to the principle of \